}

Earth Clocks

2006/03/01 Galarraga Aiestaran, Ana - Elhuyar Zientzia Iturria: Elhuyar aldizkaria

The detectives of the films, as soon as they reach the place of the crime, try to collect as many clues as they can to draw conclusions. The key is to answer the following questions: What happened? When? Why? Who has done it? Geologists and paleontologists act like detectives. To complete the puzzle of the history of the Earth it is essential to know the origin of the remains, for which the detectives of the past use different methods.
Earth Clocks
01/03/2006 | Galarraga Aiestaran, Ana | Elhuyar Zientzia Komunikazioa

(Photo: Archive)
At the University of the Basque Country there are detectives of this type, among them the paleontologist Xabier Murelaga. To clarify what has happened in one place, it is essential to date and chronologically order the geological phenomena that have occurred on earth, that is to say, order them from older to younger.

It doesn't really seem difficult. Normally the sediments are placed on horizontal layers, one over another, being younger than the lower of the upper layer. Specifically they are called law of horizontality and principle of overlapping layers, respectively. They were exposed in 1669 by a naturalist named Steno and, although they are simple, they are very useful for chronologically ordering the layers.

However, there are phenomena that break the Steno principle: earthquakes, eruptions, folds... If so, there are always traces left, which geologists seek. These tracks are polarity criteria that allow you to know if there have been changes.

It is very important to determine where and how the remains found in the excavation were.
X. Murelaga

For example, observing the footsteps know what layer there was at the time when you stepped on it, since it is impossible to tread the bottom. Water drops or crack marks are always on the surface. Another way to rely on hollow fillers. When there is a gap and it is not filled in its entirety, the filling is always at the bottom, so that, once formed the rock, the position of the filling indicates the bottom. They are called geopetal betas.

However, like all laws, the principle of overlap also has exceptions. Murelaga tells us about the terraces and caves of the rivers. In fact, on the banks of the rivers the younger layers are the lower ones, since the rivers always go into the ground. In the caves, on the contrary, you can fill the gap with sediments and, once full, create a stream below. If the water then disappears, the bottom hole is also filled and, even if it is below, it is younger than the one above.

Relative, absolute

Except for exceptions, the layer overlay principle is very useful for sorting layers over time. However, it does not indicate the age of the layers. Therefore, it is a relative, not absolute dating method.

Fossils also serve for relative dating, as each epoch contains its own fossils. Archaeologists, for example, use industry, that is, man-made utensils, to differentiate the times: Magdaleniense, Solutrense... These cultures are defined by their own industry.

However, we must bear in mind that the industry is not synchronous, it is not created and developed simultaneously throughout Europe. On the contrary, by the time it arises in one place and expands to others, time passes. This creates problems in the development of dating and correlations.

Excavation in Lardero de La Rioja. Micromammal fossils of Miocene B have been stored in the sacks for further dating.
X. Murelaga
Murelaga and other paleontologists usually work with pre-archaeological fossils, that is, prior to the appearance of man, but, however, they have the same problem with continental fossils. And it is that, until a new species reaches here, it is possible that thousands of years pass. This does not happen with marine fossils, as living things expand much faster by sea.

Despite the problems, after chronologically sorting the layers by stratigraphy, you can place each in its time from the fossils. But with this you cannot specify age, for this you must use absolute dating.

The younger the rocks, the easier the absolute dating. If you are younger than 50,000 years ago and have organic matter, you can use the 14 carbon method. It is the simplest and most used method. In addition, it has a small error, close to one hundred years or even lower.

Radioactive isotopes

The truth is that living beings absorb the 14 carbon around them while living. However, from the moment of his death, the 14 carbon begins to disappear. The pace of disappearance is known, so the footprint can be known by comparing the remaining 14 carbon with the existing one in the atmosphere.

In the photo, the paleontologist looks at the orientation of a crocodile bone to see if there are signs of river current.
X. Murelaga

Carbon isotopes are not only used to calculate age. For example, Murelaga relies on the carbon and nitrogen isotopes of deer fossils to find out what these animals ate. Thanks to the diet, Murelaga deduces the climate of that time.

However, carbon 14 has a limit: it does not serve to date rocks prior to 50,000 years, since in that period of time the practically totality of carbon 14 containing the traces is disintegrated.

Data based on isotopes in rocks can also be made. In the rocks they work with isotopes of uranium, rubidium, potassium, etc. Their average life is much higher than that of 14 carbon, so they are suitable for dating rocks over 50,000 years ago.

Thus, with isotopes with a slow rate of disintegration millions of years can be regressed. The isotope of carbon 14 has an average life of 5,730 years, that is, in the year 5,730 it loses half of the carbon 14 that the fossil has. Conversely, the process of converting uranium-235 to lead -207 has an average life of 700 million years, while the lead generation process from 238 to uranium-206 is 4.5 billion years. The error is also of this measure, that is, in dates of 3,000 million years there may be an error of one or another million.

Detectives of the past choose according to the age of the rock on which isotopes base the dating. The older the rock, the longer its half-life. In addition to those already mentioned, they use rubidium extrontium, potassium argon, thorium uranium and other systems.

In the image appears Juan Cruz Larrasoaña, placing in the geological column samples to measure paleomagnetism.
X. Murelaga
However, these techniques are only valid with rocks generated at a certain time. These types of rocks are volcanic. All parts of the rock have formed simultaneously as the lava cooled. Therefore, all parts have the same isotopic value, as disintegration occurs simultaneously in all parts. This does not occur in sedimentary rocks such as conglomerates. Not all have the same isotopic value as they are made up of several parts.

Magnetism

However, researchers often employ several methods on the same rock to make the calculation as accurate as possible. Murelaga, for example, sometimes uses paleomagnetism. The method is based on the polarity changes of the Earth's magnetic field and, according to it, is a mixture of relative and absolute dating.

In bardenas layers are visible. They emerged between 21 million and 15.5 million years ago.
X. Murelaga

Currently, the negative pole is close to the north geographic pole, but in periods between 10,000 and 25,000 years this polarity is exchanged. Polarity change occurs simultaneously throughout the planet, so it is general. Thus, if the rock contains iron or other magnetic mineral and is on a molten material, the mineral is always oriented towards the magnetic pole.

Therefore, the orientation of the mineral suggests polarity and it is easy to see whether or not it coincides with the current one. This does not mean in itself that rock is noica, since polarity changes are cyclical, but paleontologists, measuring polarity in several overlapping layers, form a paleomagnetic column. It is a kind of code bar, in which the sections are represented in black and white with current polarity and against.

In the next step, the paleomagnetic column is assimilated to that of volcanic rocks emerging from the ocean bottoms. In fact, in the volcanic rocks of the ocean dorsal, the exact dating with the isotopes is used as a reference. In addition, fossils are used to "anchor" polarity changes, that is, to know more or less where the paleomagnetic column that is desired to date in the reference of the dorsal ones.

It is a complex method, but Murelaga, for example, has dated the deposits of the Bardenas. However, sometimes there are problems, for example when a river has dragged part, or when it orients water flows minerals and not magnetisms. Except in these cases, paleomagnetism is a valid method that allows travel far back in time, as it also serves to date rocks over 100 million years old.

Rings and others

Tree trunks also have a barcode: rings or growth lines. They also serve to make datations. The ring technique, called dendrochronology, is to relate growth lines to weather and weather.

In fact, the trees here are created a ring a year. Elsewhere, however, it is not. For example, in tropical rainforests plants grow constantly, while in very dry summer areas there may be more than one ring in the same year. Therefore, they do not use dendrochronology.

However, in these latitudes the trees grow more in summer than in winter. Since the initial and final wood of the growth period is different, it is possible to separate the rings. Also, the rings have a different width due to the factors that affect the growth (temperature, pollutants, etc. ). From there they get additional information, for example, how time has changed.

As with paleomagnetic columns, it is necessary to compare the ring sequence with a model. In this way it is founded, placed in chronology. On the other hand, starting with the living trees and overlapping them with pieces of dead wood, a long chronology can be achieved. Thus, the oldest trunk, dated with dendrochronology, is 7,000 years old.

Bardenas micromammal teeth: 1-7, beavers; 8-12, eomiliidos (disappeared today); 13-22, lirones; 23-24, hamsters; 25-26, squirrels; 27-29 lagomorfas.
(Photo: X. Murelaga)
In addition to all of them, there are many other dating methods: luminescence, palinology, which takes into account the hydration of obsidian... Some of them are absolute and others relative, but usually researchers use more than one to perform as accurate a calculation as possible.

A lady should not be asked how old she is, but time detectives use all the tricks at their disposal to invent the age of Earth.

Other
Taking out accounts very carefully
In samples of less than 50,000 years, the most used technique is that of 14 carbon. But that does not mean that it is cheap, but asking those who work on it. Paleontologist Xabier Murelaga has recognized that it concentrates the entire budget in the department of stratigraphy and paleontology of the UPV.
Carbon 14 tests are carried out by sending samples to foreign laboratories such as Madrid, Switzerland, Groninger or, in the case of Murelaga, Florida. Murelaga, when studying paleodiets, in addition to carbon isotopes, needs to measure nitrogen, so it sends samples to Florida. The value of dating a sample is 600 euros, so carefully choose each sample to send.
However, the UPV itself also carries out datations based on other isotopes. Specifically, in the area of Mineralogy and Petrology, they offer service of calculation of geological age to university groups as well as companies and individuals. They date rocks, minerals, metals, fossils, utensils... from elements and isotopes such as rubidium, strontium, uranium, lead, samarium and neodymium. Samario-neodymium dating is the most expensive, since it costs 180 euros per sample and with it has been calculated, for example, the age of a rock of Merida. It is a diorite with garnet estimated at 550 million years.
Galarraga de Aiestaran, Ana
Services
218
2006
Services
038
Geology